Оцінки The Blood of Dawnwalker, у гри на Opencritic 84 бали із 100 і 82 бали із 100 на Metacritic.

MonsterVine 5/5
SECTOR sk 9.5/10
Digitale Anime 9/10
But Why Tho? 9/10
The Nerd Stash 9/10
Loot Level Chill 9/10
NextPlay 9/10
Evilgamerz 9/10
One More Game 9/10
Worth Playing 8.5/10
PSX Brasil 84/100
TheSixthAxis 8/10
Xbox Achievements 80%
GRYOnline 8/10
MondoXbox 8/10
Console Creatures 8/10
Dexerto 4/5
Gameliner 3.5/5
GameRant 6/10
Digitec Magazine 3/5
The Beta Network 6/10